In the world of web scraping and data extraction, proxy services play a critical role in helping businesses bypass restrictions, access data without getting blocked, and gather information at scale. Among the most prominent players in the proxy market are Brightdata and Oxylabs, both of which offer comprehensive solutions to meet the needs of modern businesses. However, each has its unique strengths and offerings. In this article, we’ll compare Brightdata and Oxylabs across a variety of key factors to help you choose the best solution for your project.
Overview of Brightdata and Oxylabs
Brightdata, formerly known as Luminati, is one of the largest proxy providers in the world. With a massive proxy pool and years of experience in the market, Brightdata is known for offering residential, mobile, datacenter, and static residential proxies. It provides robust infrastructure for web scraping and is used by developers and businesses worldwide for a variety of use cases.
Oxylabs, on the other hand, is a premium proxy provider that focuses on ethical sourcing and high-quality proxy services. Known for its reliable and diverse proxy offerings, Oxylabs has established itself as a leader in the field of public data gathering. It is widely used for tasks such as e-commerce price monitoring, brand protection, and cybersecurity.
In this article, we will compare Brightdata and Oxylabs across several important categories such as proxy types, pricing, scalability, and ease of use. To make the comparison clearer, we’ll also provide a detailed table.
Comparison of Key Features
Below is a comparison table summarizing the key features of Brightdata and Oxylabs:
Feature
Brightdata
Oxylabs
Company Overview
Formerly Luminati, one of the largest proxy providers
Leading provider of ethical proxies and scraping tools
Wide selection of residential IPs across the world
Ethical sourcing with Tier A+ model IPs
Mobile Proxies
Real mobile device IPs
Real mobile device IPs
Datacenter Proxies
High-speed proxies suitable for large-scale scraping
Fast, cost-effective proxies, suitable for intensive tasks
Static Residential Proxies
Yes
No
Pricing
Starts at $2.2 per GB for Residential proxies
Starts at $8 per GB for Residential proxies
Mobile Proxies Pricing
Starts at $4.5 per GB
Starts at $9 per GB
Datacenter Proxies Pricing
Starts at $0.075 per IP
Starts at $50 per IP
Dedicated Datacenter Pricing
Yes
Starts at $8.25 per IP
Scraper API
Yes, with integrations for Python, Java, Node.js, etc.
Yes, the same as before
Web Unblocker
No
Yes, AI-powered Web Unblocker
OxyCopilot
No
Yes, AI-powered assistant for web scraping automation
Support
24/7 support, dedicated account managers for enterprise customers
24/7 support, specialized technical support for enterprises
Proxy Manager
Yes, for managing proxy settings
No
Network Speed
High-speed proxies for efficient scraping
Premium speed with low latency
Free Trial
Yes
Yes, limited trial available
Security Certifications
No explicit certifications
ISO-27001, ISO-50001, ISO-14001 certifications
Key Differences Between Brightdata and Oxylabs
1. Proxy Types and Network Size
Both Brightdata and Oxylabs offer a wide variety of proxies, including residential, mobile, and datacenter proxies. However, Oxylabs has a larger proxy pool, with 100M+ IPs, compared to Brightdata’s 65M+ IPs. Oxylabs also offers dedicated datacenter proxies, which are designed for high-performance tasks.
Brightdata stands out with its static residential proxies, a hybrid option that combines the authenticity of residential IPs with the stability of datacenter proxies. This makes it a good choice for customers who need the benefits of both types.
2. Pricing
In terms of pricing, Brightdata tends to be more affordable, especially for datacenter proxies and residential proxies. The pricing for residential proxies at Brightdata starts at $2.2 per GB, while Oxylabs begins at $8 per GB. Similarly, mobile proxies and datacenter proxies are priced more competitively at Brightdata.
However, Oxylabs offers superior performance, reliability, and AI-powered tools like OxyCopilot and the Web Unblocker, which justify the higher costs.
3. Ethical Sourcing and Certifications
Oxylabs places a strong emphasis on ethical sourcing and has several ISO certifications (ISO-27001, ISO-50001, ISO-14001), ensuring the highest standards for security, environmental practices, and sustainability. The company also has a pro bono initiative, Project 4β, which helps academic institutions and NGOs with public data gathering.
Brightdata also focuses on ethical sourcing, but it does not have the same range of certifications as Oxylabs, making Oxylabs a better choice for customers who require certified ethical sourcing and compliance.
4. AI Tools and Automation
One of the standout features of Oxylabs is OxyCopilot, an AI-powered assistant designed to help users automate data collection across diverse website structures. It allows users to input English-language prompts and receive structured data without manual coding. This makes Oxylabs particularly attractive to businesses that need to scale their data scraping without hiring developers for every task.
Brightdata, while offering robust tools for developers, lacks a comparable AI assistant like OxyCopilot, making Oxylabs the better choice for businesses looking for AI-driven automation.
5. Support and Documentation
Both companies offer 24/7 support with dedicated account managers for enterprise clients. However, Oxylabs provides additional specialized support for technical enterprises and offers comprehensive documentation and code examples for multiple programming languages. Brightdata, on the other hand, offers extensive community support and developer-focused resources, which is a great choice for independent developers.
6. Use Cases
Both Brightdata and Oxylabs are widely used in industries such as e-commerce, advertising, SEO, and market research. However, Oxylabs also has a strong focus on brand protection and cybersecurity, making it a better fit for companies in these sectors. Brightdata, with its lower pricing and extensive proxy types, is a good choice for businesses that need high-scale data scraping across multiple industries.
Conclusion: Which One Should You Choose?
Choose Brightdata if:
You are looking for affordable pricing, especially for datacenter proxies and static residential proxies.
You need a large-scale proxy pool with a variety of proxy types.
Your focus is on competitive intelligence and market research, where the primary need is gathering public data at scale.
Choose Oxylabs if:
You require high-quality, ethical proxies with AI-powered automation and advanced features like OxyCopilot and the Web Unblocker.
You are involved in industries like cybersecurity, brand protection, and e-commerce price monitoring where reliability and compliance are key.
You need premium support, including ISO certifications and technical expertise.
MoMoProxy: A Viable Alternative
While Brightdata and Oxylabs are two leading names in the proxy market, another emerging provider, MoMoProxy, is becoming a popular alternative. Offering competitive pricing, high success rates, and fast response times, MoMoProxy stands out as an affordable yet reliable option for many users.
Comparison of MoMoProxy Against Top Proxy Providers
Here's a comparison of MoMoProxy, Oxylabs, SmartProxy, and Brightdata based on key metrics such as success rate, response time, and pricing:
Feature
MoMoProxy
Oxylabs
SmartProxy
Brightdata
Success Rate (50 IPs)
100%
99.82%
99.68%
98.96%
Response Time
0.51s
0.41s (fastest)
0.54s
1.12s (slowest)
Start Price (per GB)
$3.2
$8
$7
$8.4
1,000GB Bulk Price
$1,200
$4,000
$3,000
$3,000–$4,000 (contact support for details)
Key Insights for MoMoProxy
MoMoProxy offers the highest success rate at 100% for 50 IPs, meaning it's incredibly reliable for avoiding IP blocks.
The response time of 0.51s is fast and competitive, just behind Oxylabs, which has the fastest at 0.41s.
Pricing is where MoMoProxy really shines, offering the lowest price at $3.2 per GB, far more affordable than Oxylabs and Brightdata.
Conclusion
MoMoProxy offers an excellent balance of performance and cost-efficiency, with a 100% success rate, competitive response time, and the most affordable pricing in the market.
Oxylabs is the go-to provider if you need premium features, AI-powered tools, and fastest response times, though it comes at a higher cost.
Brightdata is ideal for large-scale scraping needs, particularly for global coverage and a vast range of proxy types, but it can be quite expensive, especially for bulk users.
For businesses or developers looking for a reliable and affordable proxy provider, MoMoProxy is a strong contender in the market, offering a great alternative to the more expensive options of Oxylabs and Brightdata.
