Choosing the right proxy service can make or break your web scraping, data collection, or market research projects. In this comprehensive 2024 comparison, we analyze four industry leaders: Decodo (formerly Smartproxy) for budget-conscious users, Bright Data for enterprise-grade solutions, Oxylabs for AI-powered scraping, and NetNut for B2B reliability. We'll break down their proxy networks (from 85M to 175M+ IPs), pricing (starting as low as $0.026/IP), unique features like Oxylabs' OxyCopilot AI assistant, and ideal use cases to help you make an informed decision. Whether you need cost-effective proxies, compliance-ready solutions, or 100% success rates, this guide covers all critical factors for businesses and developers.

Decodo (formerly Smartproxy) offers affordable, high-performance proxies with a focus on simplicity and ease of use. It's ideal for startups, small businesses, and developers who need cost-effective proxies without sacrificing reliability.

• Price: Starts at $1.5/GB
• Features:
  • 125M+ real residential IPs
  • 195+ countries with city-level targeting
  • Unlimited concurrent sessions
  • HTTP/HTTPS/SOCKS5 support
• Best For: Web scraping, ad verification, sneaker copping

• Price: Starts at $0.32/IP
• Features:
  • ISP-assigned IPs (blend of residential authenticity and datacenter stability)
  • Ideal for long-term sessions (e.g., social media automation)
• Best For: Multi-accounting, social media management

• Price: Starts at $4.5/GB
• Features:
  • 20M+ mobile IPs (3G/4G/5G)
  • Carrier-level targeting
• Best For: Mobile app testing, localized ad verification

• Price: Starts at $0.026/IP (cheapest in the market)
• Features:
  • 150K+ IPs, high-speed connections
  • Ideal for bulk data collection
• Best For: High-volume scraping, price monitoring

• Price: Starts at $1.6/1K requests
• Features:
  • CAPTCHA bypass, IP rotation, anti-ban technology
• Best For: Scraping heavily protected websites (e.g., Amazon, Google)

• X Browser – Dedicated proxy browser
• Chrome/Firefox Proxy Extensions – Easy proxy management
• Proxy Checker – Validate proxy performance

✅ Pros:

• Most affordable datacenter proxies ($0.026/IP)
• Simple pricing (no hidden fees)
• Free browser tools for easy setup

❌ Cons:

• Fewer pre-built datasets compared to Bright Data/Oxylabs
• No AI-driven automation (unlike Oxylabs' OxyCopilot)

---

Bright Data (formerly Luminati) is the industry leader in large-scale data collection, offering enterprise-grade proxies, datasets, and managed services. It's trusted by Fortune 500 companies for compliance and reliability.

• Price: Custom (free tier available)
• Features:
  • 150M+ peer-to-peer residential IPs
  • City, ASN, and carrier-level targeting
  • Zero CAPTCHAs with Web Unlocker
• Best For: Large-scale web scraping, market intelligence

• Price: Custom
• Features:
  • ISP-assigned IPs (high trust score)
  • Bypass tough anti-bot systems
• Best For: E-commerce scraping, banking data

• Price: Custom
• Features:
  • Real mobile IPs (3G/4G/5G)
  • Carrier-specific targeting
• Best For: Mobile ad fraud detection, app testing

• Price: Starts at $0.10/IP
• Features:
  • High-speed, unlimited bandwidth
  • Rotating & static options
• Best For: High-speed data extraction

• Price: Custom
• Features:
  • AI-powered CAPTCHA solving
  • Auto-retry on IP bans
• Best For: Scraping Google, Amazon, and LinkedIn

• Dataset Marketplace (pre-collected retail, LinkedIn, and social media data)
• Managed Services (hands-free data delivery)
• GDPR/KYC Compliance (enterprise-grade security)

✅ Pros:

• Best compliance (GDPR, CCPA, KYC)
• Largest proxy network (150M+ IPs)
• Pre-built datasets for AI/ML

❌ Cons:

• Expensive for small businesses
• Complex pricing (custom quotes)

---

Oxylabs specializes in AI-ready data collection, offering OxyCopilot (AI-powered scraping) and the largest proxy pool (175M+ IPs). It's ideal for AI/ML teams and developers who need automated, no-code solutions.

• Price: $7.5/GB (50% off promo)
• Features:
  • 175M+ ethically sourced IPs
  • City-level targeting, unlimited sessions
• Best For: SEO monitoring, travel fare aggregation

• Price: Custom
• Features:
  • Bypass blocks using trusted ASNs
• Best For: Banking, financial data scraping

• Price: Custom
• Features:
  • 20M+ mobile IPs (carrier-level targeting)
• Best For: Mobile app analytics

• Price: Starts at $0.50/IP
• Features:
  • Fast, dedicated IPs
• Best For: High-speed scraping

• Price: Custom
• Features:
  • AI-powered, zero blocks
• Best For: Scraping Amazon, Google, and social media

• OxyCopilot – AI assistant for no-code scraping
• Video Datasets – AI/ML-ready data
• ISO 27001 Certified – High security standards

✅ Pros:

• Best for AI/ML (video datasets, OxyCopilot)
• Largest proxy pool (175M+ IPs)
• No-code automation

❌ Cons:

• Expensive for small projects
• Steeper learning curve for beginners

---

NetNut focuses on B2B compliance, offering 85M+ residential IPs with 100% success rates. It's ideal for businesses needing zero-block scraping.

• Price: $210/72GB (~$2.9/GB)
• Features:
  • 85M+ IPs, city-level targeting
  • Zero CAPTCHAs, 100% success rate
• Best For: E-commerce, travel aggregation

• Price: Custom
• Features:
  • 5M+ mobile IPs (3G/4G/5G)
• Best For: Mobile app testing

• Price: Custom
• Features:
  • 1M+ IPs, 24/7 availability
• Best For: Social media automation

• Price: Custom
• Features:
  • 150K+ IPs, 99.99% uptime
• Best For: High-performance scraping

• B2B-Sourced IPs (no personal data risks)
• User-Friendly Dashboard – Real-time proxy management
• 100% Success Rate Claim – Reliable for mission-critical tasks

✅ Pros:

• Best for B2B compliance
• Zero-block scraping
• Transparent pricing

❌ Cons:

• Smaller proxy pool vs. Oxylabs/Bright Data
• Fewer AI/ML integrations

---

• Decodo = Best for affordable, simple proxies
• Bright Data = Best for enterprise compliance
• Oxylabs = Best for AI/ML automation
• NetNut = Best for B2B & zero-block scraping